Enlarge

Among the counterfeit Panda 1-ounce silver bullion coins passed at Coins+ in Cincinnati were these two pieces, dated 2003 and 2009.

Counterfeit silver bullion coins, rounds and bars have plagued the numismatic marketplace for several years, but some in the hobby are seeing what might be a surge of some fakes.

Counterfeits of some of the bullion pieces have been around for a number of years, though increasing numbers are showing up, and manufacturing methods have made some pieces more highly deceptive.
Over the past month, in its weekly issues, Coin World has reported on counterfeit American Prospector 1-ounce silver rounds being offered in the United States and fake 2011 American Eagle silver bullion coins surfacing in Canada. The latest report is from Cincinnati, of fake 1-ounce Chinese Panda bullion coins.
While the attempted sellers of such fake bullion items often go untouched by authorities, not all do. Police in Denton, Texas, have arrested a local man on eight counts associated with the sale of fake American Prospector rounds at pawn shops and jewelry stores in that area.

Regardless of design, many purported silver pieces that have duped collectors and dealers alike have been found to contain no silver at all. Most have been composed of various concentrations of copper, nickel and zinc in place of the .999 fine silver found in most genuine silver bullion items.

The deception is often uncovered only after a sale has taken place, when destructive testing of individual pieces reveals the absence of any precious metals. By that time, however, the seller is nowhere to be found.

Some pieces are offered as novelty items and advertised by the original sellers as fabricated from base metals plated with .999 fine silver, but carry designs suggesting a composition of pure silver. In secondary sales, an unsuspecting buyer, unaware that a piece is plated base metal, may buy it as genuine silver and never learn of its authenticity until years later when preparing to resell the item.

Proactive response

Confronted with the ever-increasing proliferation of counterfeits of its products in the market, officials at Sunshine Minting Inc. during the past year took action by rebranding all of the firm’s precious metals products and producing them with anti-counterfeiting bullion security devices.

Sunshine Minting Inc., in Coeur d’Alene, Idaho, is now producing its new bullion products bearing the Mint Mark SI security technology.

Sunshine Minting is a private minting facility that strikes and sells its own brand of gold and silver products in various weights, each bearing the company name. Sunshine is also the primary supplier of planchets to the U.S. Mint for silver American Eagles.

Tom Power, president and chief executive officer of Sunshine, said Feb. 13 that the company has been assertive in trying to remove counterfeit Sunshine Minting products from the marketplace and prevent any further sale.

When offerings are noted on eBay, Alibaba and through other venues, Power said the company will take the necessary steps to protect the Sunshine brand. Power said eBay has been extremely cooperative in removing such items for sale.

Many of the fake Sunshine products appearing on the market bearing older designs have been found to be struck in either solely base metals or base metals plated with a thin coating of precious metal.

“Sunshine Minting, Inc. does not manufacture nor sell our bullion products as ‘silver-plated’ or ‘clad,’ ” Power said. “These are counterfeit versions that are being illegally represented as SMI products when, in fact, they are not manufactured by Sunshine Minting. SMI is taking every legal measure that we can to thwart this influx of counterfeit product and protect our reputation as the leading manufacturer of bullion products.”
Sunshine’s newly branded bullion products are being struck containing Mint Mark SI, a “Scrambled Indicia” security feature that was originally developed for the printing industry by Graphic Security Systems Corp., located in Lake Worth, Fla.

Sunshine is the first mint to develop this technology for use on bullion products, according to Sunshine.
Sunshine’s hallmark, featuring an eagle in flight with the sun and rays in the background, dominates the new obverse design of its bullion products. The weight and fineness are also stamped incuse on the obverse.

Gold bars are certified to be .9999 fine, ranging in size from 1 gram to 100 grams; are serialized; and are housed in specialized Tamper Evident Packaging. Silver bars and rounds will feature the Sunshine Minting hallmark and are certified to be .999 fine and range in size from a half ounce to 100 ounces.

The Mint Mark SI security devices are located in the middle of the reverse of each of the newly produced bullion products. The security devices are invisible to the naked eye and are readable only by using a special decoder.

The decoder, approximately the size of a credit card, reveals the primary security device when the decoder is passed over the central circular device.

Microprinting readable through magnification appears around the top and bottom border of the central device, appearing as MINT MARK SI.

Passing the decoder over the central reverse design reveals the first security device, appearing as VALID, between the MINT MARK SI microprinting. Turning the decoder 90 degrees counterclockwise reveals the second security device in the same location, with the word VALID replaced with a sun and rays motif.
The security devices are also visible using an adaptor made for the iPhone.

Power said approximately 1 million Sunshine Mint bullion pieces containing the security devices have been introduced into the market over the past six months.

Reported counterfeits

It is believed that many of the counterfeit silver bullion pieces offered online and elsewhere have infiltrated the marketplace from suppliers in China.

A website at http://theeyeballkid.hubpages.com/hub/Fake-silver-bars-and-coins details and demonstrates how to detect some of the counterfeit pieces that have popped up intermittently. Listed pieces include fakes of 1-ounce .999 fine silver Pan American bars, Scottsdale bars, Sunshine Mint bars, American Prospector rounds, Chinese Panda silver coins, Australian Lunar Dragon bullion coins and Canadian Maple Leaf bullion coins, as well as generic 1-ounce silver bars.

Officials at Coins+ in Cincinnati reported that, on Feb. 5, the firm purchased 42 of what were believed to be Chinese Panda 1-ounce bullion coins of various dates from 2003 through 2011.

Later, after the seller had left the store, an acid test was conducted, determining the pieces in the lot were counterfeit, according to Coins+.

In addition to acid tests, one can also check specifications for weight and diameter, and conduct a ring test against a genuine piece. It can also be useful to compare design elements.
A genuine Panda 1-ounce .999 fine silver bullion coin should measure 40 millimeters in diameter and 2.95 millimeters thick and weigh 31.101 grams.

A 2009-dated counterfeit among those fakes sold to Coins+ measured 39.72 millimeters in diameter, had a thickness ranging from 3.91 to 3.97 millimeters depending on where the measurement was taken on the rim, and weighed 31.1844 grams. A genuine 2013 Panda silver bullion coin emits a high-pitched ring when tested. The 2009 counterfeit emits almost no ring.

Many silver bullion coins and rounds bear vertical edge reeding. All of the fakes Coins+ purchased had edge reeding positioned diagonally.

However, orientation of edge reeding is not an absolute diagnostic; the genuine 2013 silver Pandas bear diagonal edge reeding.

Orientation of edge reeding has varied on the edge of silver Pandas depending on the year of issue, according to William Graessle, vice president of sales for PandaAmerica in Torrance, Calif.

The obverse design of genuine Panda silver coins depicting a Panda motif changes annually. The reverse depicts the 15th century Hall of Prayer for Abundant Harvest in the Temple of Heaven; while the central device on the reverse has remained the same, the reverse treatment, placement of other elements and width of rim have changed over the years. The first version of the reverse was used from 1989 to 1991; the second reverse was used from 1992 to 1999; and the third reverse has been used since 2000.

Depending on the year of issue and the design, which details are frosted and which are mirrored like Proof varies.

Graessle said the genuine Panda silver coins generally exhibit heavier frosting on the devices than is seen on the fake pieces.

A listing of varieties on the genuine versions can be found at the “Panda Varieties” link from the PandaAmerica website at www.pandaamerica.com/.

Prospector arrest

Jordan Alan Pettit, 26, whose address is listed on bond records as Richardson, Texas, but which investigators report as Garland, faces seven individual misdemeanor counts of deceptive business practices filed by the Denton Police Department and one count of deceptive business practices filed by the Denton County Sheriff’s Department. Pettit remains free on bond pending court appearances. No court dates to answer any of the eight charges had been set as of Feb. 13.

A spokesman for the Denton Police Department told Coin World Feb. 12 that Pettit is alleged to have passed fake American Prospector rounds at several local pawn shops and jewelry stores.

Pettit is alleged to have passed fake rounds five times at one pawn shop by pawning the items for cash, then not returning to pick up the merchandise, according to the police department spokesman. Employees at one jewelry store did not realize they had been duped until they decided to try to melt one of the Prospector pieces to use the metal for jewelry repair, and the color of the metal was wrong when heat was applied, according to the police.

Counterfeit American Prospector silver rounds have been in the market for a number of years, but began appearing in larger numbers in 2012.

Examples have been offered online on eBay, and Coin World has received recent reports of pieces being offered over the counter to dealers in the Bay City/Saginaw areas of Michigan.

Comparison of an example of a fake American Prospector round to a genuine example shows attributes that can be used in authentication. The counterfeit piece used for this comparison was purchased by an unidentified dealer through an eBay sale and provided to Coin World by Texas dealer Mike Fuljenz. The genuine example was supplied to Coin World by Dillon Gage, a worldwide bullion firm based in Dallas. Comparison of the two pieces yielded the following diagnostic attributes:

➤ The counterfeit exhibits frosted devices against Proof fields while the genuine piece has the duller, uniform surface texture that one normally finds on a strictly bullion piece.

➤ The genuine piece has a higher, pure ring when tapped with a hard object while perched on the end of one’s fingers, while the fake round has a duller sound.

➤ The genuine piece is 40mm in diameter and weighs 31.103 grams; the fake piece is slightly smaller in diameter but weighs 31.184 grams.

➤ On the genuine obverse, the contents of the prospector’s pan and the pan itself are more defined than on the fake. In the photo illustrations, notice the differences in the rendition of the water movement, shoreline details and their placement in relation to the inscriptions.

➤ On the reverse, the big E design device on the fake has a somewhat flat frosting, while the surface of the E on the genuine piece is pebbled. The inside top of the G in the inscription ENGELHARD is notched on the genuine piece; the G is rounded out on the fake.

➤ The longitude and latitude lines of the globe logo are tight to, but not touching, the big E device on the genuine piece; on the fake, the lines are distant from the E.

➤ The outer border on the globe is complete on the genuine piece, but broken just above the N in the word ONE on the fake.

The Feb. 18 Coin World reported the appearance of counterfeit 2011 American Eagle silver bullion coins in Toronto. Results of a spectrographic analysis of one of the counterfeit American Eagles determined a composition of 50.4753 percent nickel; 39.3614 percent copper; 10.1163 percent zinc; and 0.0271 percent gold.

In comparison, spectrographic analysis of a counterfeit 1984 American Prospector round from among those obtained in 2012 on eBay indicated a composition of 60 percent copper, 39 percent zinc and 1 percent nickel.

Other resources

Numismatic Guaranty Corp. has published online articles devoted to what its grading staff has encountered among questionable bullion pieces submitted for grading, archived at www.ngccoin.com/news/Landing.aspx?SeriesID=7. ■

Enlarge

In 2011, the United States Mint began selling official commemorative medals commemorating the 10th anniversary of the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.

An issuer of commemorative coins and medals marking the 10th anniversary of the terrorist attack of Sept. 11, 2001, has agreed to pay $750,000 to settle Federal Trade Commission charges.

The firm, National Collector’s Mint, faced four charges of violation of the FTC Act and one charge of violating the Hobby Protection Act. The settlement is not an admission that laws were violated.

According to the FTC, Sept. 11, 2001, anniversary coins from Liberia sold by National Collector’s Mint are not sanctioned or endorsed by the United States government, and therefore are a violation of the Hobby Protection Act because they lack the word “copy.”

National Collector’s Mint is a Delaware-based corporation with offices in Port Chester, N.Y.

In a complaint for permanent injunction filed in the United States District Court, Southern District of New York, the FTC claims that NCM engaged in “deceptive marketing and sales of coins and collectibles” and NCM “prey[ed] on consumers’ desire to purchase purportedly valuable coins and collectibles.”

As part of the settlement, which remains subject to court approval, the NCM agrees not to misrepresent material facts about its products and services, and to clearly disclose, before a customer consents to pay for anything, the total costs and fees, any refund policy, and any limitation or condition that applies.

Coin, medal comparison

The complaint cites a noncirculating legal tender dollar coin issued by the firm on behalf of Liberia with a legend declaring 10TH ANNIVERSARY SEPTEMBER 11TH COMMEMORATIVE, that was sold for $29.95.

The obverse features a three-piece design, with each of the three pieces separately struck and then assembled. The main planchet into which the other two pieces are inserted depicts a section of the New York City skyline. The separate pieces rendered of the Twin Towers of the World Trade Center and the USS New York are made from copper and clad in 14 milligrams of .999 fine silver reported by NCM to have been recovered from Ground Zero.

The reverse bears REPUBLIC OF LIBERIA on a base below an eagle, with the denomination ONE DOLLAR along the bottom border.

Advertising for the coin suggested it was “exclusively authorized” and paid “homage to America’s heroes and remember[s] the day that changed America forever.”

The FTC complaint cited the potential for consumer confusion over the National Collector’s Mint’s products and official products of the United States.

The U.S. Congress authorized a national commemorative medal to mark the 10th anniversary of the terrorist attacks, and the United States Mint began selling the medal (in two Mint mark versions) in June 2011. Sales of the medal included a $10 surcharge per medal to be directed to the National September 11th Memorial and Museum.

The complaint notes that “defendants have sold and continue to sell their 9/11 commemorative at the same time that the U.S. Mint sells the original medal.”

The FTC calls the Liberian coins “imitation numismatic items” as defined by the Hobby Protection Act, which states that “‘imitation numismatic item’ means an item which purports to be, but in fact is not, an original numismatic item or which is a reproduction, copy, or counterfeit of an original numismatic item.”

Because of “consumer confusion,” the FTC claimed, the United States Mint published a consumer alert warning customers that “the only official United States coin or medal to commemorate the 10th anniversary of the September 11th attacks is the ‘National September 11th Memorial & Museum Commemorative Medal.’”

The FTC cited National Collector’s Mint for what it termed a “misleading and deceptive” ordering and return process, generating four violations of the FTC Act.

National Collectors Mint was charged with failure to disclose material aspects of the refund policy; mailing unordered merchandise; failure to disclose material refund policy terms; and failure to disclose total costs.

The FTC claimed the company used an automated telephone system that led consumers to receive merchandise that they had not ordered, “despite their repeated attempts to decline additional items.” NCM also allegedly “fail[ed] to disclose, or to disclose adequately, material terms and limitations of their guarantee and return policy.”

Consumers were unable in many cases to reach an NCM customer service representative.

According to the FTC, the National Collector’s Mint has generated more than $22 million in sales from more than 230 “varieties” of Sept. 11-related coins and other collectibles since 2008.

NCM advertising for the 9/11 commems included the disclaimer, “Not affiliated, licensed or endorsed by the US Gov’t or the US Mint.”

The 9/11 commemorative pieces offered by NCM were struck on Proof planchets of copper layered with 14 milligrams of 24-karat gold. ■

Other News & Articles

• Two Dead, One Injured After Coin Robbery
• Chinese Display Star of Hong Kong Event
• ANA Names Money Show Host Clubs